Friday, September 21, 2018

Reflection #1 - SPPT 5999


Enacting the Work of Language Instruction:
·      Summary –
o   Overall, this chapter gives foreign language teachers a guide for how to teach the language meaningfully to students. One important focus in the chapter is providing input and output to the students in meaningful ways and through a variety of modalities. The other important focus is on the production of language by the students themselves, letting the students “run the show” to say, where lessons are based on content/culture, but structured in ways in which the students can show what they know, but are challenged to learn more and new things whether that is through comprehension checks, modeling by the teacher, or self-reflecting on their own work to find the errors or gaps in their language.
·      Key concepts –
o   Comprehensible input vs comprehensible output
§  ZPD (zone of proximal development) and challenging learners to show what they know
§  Helps find gaps in learning
o   Modified interaction
§  More input processed = more language learned and internalized
§  COLLABORATIVE > students work together to troubleshoot their own problems and/or negotiate with teacher/other students/other people in the world
§  “Help students through the language, not about language”
o   Sociocultural theory
§  Language and culture must be mixed > the two cannot be separated in the “real world” aka away from the classroom
o   Context = meaningful places for TL (target language) to exist and be comprehended
§  Teachers must provide transitions between activities that maintain context for language, which contributes to meaningful learning and fluid/connected learning
·      Reaction –
o   I thought this chapter was very helpful, and a great follow-up from a meeting I had with my supervisor this morning prior to having her come and observe my class this coming week. I personally struggle with transitioning between activities and providing context to my students for everything we do. I will sometimes provide context for some activities, but I forget to do it for all activities. In addition, this chapter lays out the most important things to keep in mind and having “7 steps” or “7 (strong) recommendations” is more manageable than trying to think of every piece of advice every teacher or collogue has every given to me.
·      Questions –
o   There may be no perfect model for teaching, but is there a structure or lesson plan flow that is the “best” or significantly better than others?
o   Although I am teaching Spanish 1022, does this model look different for those in a 1001 course?

From Input to Output:
·      Summary –
o   The chapter begins with a comprehensive definition and examples of what input is and why it is an important aspect of learning. The reader is walked through how an L2 learner can get from input to output through a variety of factors such as, but not limited to, working memory, intake, parsing, event probability, and semantics. All of these things help make input meaningful and provide a context in which the learner can absorb the input.
·      Key concepts –
o   Input
§  “The language that a learner hears (or reads) that has some kind of communicative intent” (Vanpetten, 25) > language a learner is supposed to attend to
§  Learners react through understanding or doing what the speaker is asking of them > making connections through what was spoken or read
§  “Acquisition happens as a byproduct of comprehension” (Vanpetten, 26)
§  Half of language learning/communication!
o   Immersion
§  Being surrounded by the TL
§  Can be through studying abroad or school programs or speaking it with a specific person/group of people (ex: Spanish spoken at home with family)
§  Can be a context for input and output practice
o   Intake
§  Parts of language you remember in your working memory
§  Can be words, phrases, or whole sentence/theme chunks
§  A means in which a learner (L1, L2, etc.) receives language and then uses to produce output
·      Reaction –
o   I found this chapter not as useful for me, and quite long. It could be because I spent four years in undergrad and two years of research learning about language acquisition through the Speech-Language-Hearing Sciences department, so a lot of this is intuitive for me. I find it interesting that L2 learners must go through a similar process as L1 learners of a language, and it helps me to take a step back and empathize with my students more. I have had 12-13 years of Spanish, and 2 immersive experiences so I am the expert in my class while teaching, but I must remember that my students are not at the same level and need more aid (input being part of that) than I would in a classroom setting.
·      Questions –
o   What are ways I can practice parsing with my students without infantilizing them?
o   The chapter says that “grammatical forms that are redundant do not contribute to any real meaning to the sentence,” however the previous article stated the importance of reiterating perhaps new things to students. Are these two things compatible? Why?

Friday, September 14, 2018

Beginning the Teaching of a Foreign Language Journey - SPPT 5999


As some of you may know, I began grad school just a couple weeks ago. Being in grad school entails three main tasks: teaching, learning, and researching. The last one has yet to begin, but the other two are in full swing, and boy is it a learning curve. This post will mainly focus on the teaching aspect seeing as one of my assignments is for a course on teaching methodology/pedagogy.

This past week, three articles* were given to the class to read that discussed different, but important, ways of teaching foreign languages. Let’s all start on the same page: teaching a foreign language is not the same as teaching a different subject. In fact, teaching a foreign language, I would argue, is much more difficult! Teaching foreign language should encompass content, culture, implicit grammar, vocab, etc. I am fighting to use my second language and help my students develop of second language (which means by nature, I am fighting with English for control in my brain and the brains of my students.)

One difficult I am facing is how to present different countries and cultures in the Hispanophone world. Spanish is the official language for twenty-one countries! It is a significant minority language in four countries, a historical language in two countries, a creole language in four countries, and has been transformed into a Judeo-language spoken by some Sephardi Jews in Israel today.** How do I not reduce these rich, and vibrant cultures into things such as “In Argentina they drink mate,” and “In Spain, ‘lisps’ sound familiar,” etc.

Carol Klee, a tenured professor at the University of Minnesota answered this for me, saying that it’s important to “focus on themes… [things] like ‘women’ and what’s happening in areas of society with women… So, focusing on broader themes rather than the countries themselves.”

All of the articles that I read for class mentioned or focused on the integration of culture in foreign language teaching and the importance of it as the Hispanophone world is so diverse, and it gives content from which we can teach. Integrating culture not only gives a foundation for vocab and the use of grammar in a real, communicative way, but also brings light to places that might otherwise be forgotten as Hispanophone. “And there is still a struggle to find a balance between content and language, particularly in the first-year,” Carol adds. This is an area in which I am still trying to find balance.

Another focus of all three articles is the importance of communicative learning and encouraging proficiency in students. The ACTFL gives very detailed guidelines for the levels of proficiency, and it is expected that students jump from whatever level of novice he/she is to intermediate-low by the end of the semester with me.

Carol comments on this as well when I asked if there was a model that works best for teaching foreign languages: “More student-centered methods work best… When I started teaching as a graduate student, we were still transitioning from audio-lingual… teacher centered [teaching.] And as the years passed, it transitioned from more teacher-centered to student-centered, group activities, and communicative language teaching.”

I also interviewed Bill Viestenz, an associate professor of Spanish and Global Studies at the University of Minnesota and asked what good foreign language teaching looks like (hoping to incur some wisdom as I begin my own teaching journey.) He responded, writing, “I think that good foreign language teaching frames the intersection of culture and linguistic competency in a productive and logical way. Good language instruction is able to augment the student's linguistic competency through modeling and performance rather than through too much dependence on meta-linguistic demonstration.”

Across the board, there is an emphasis on communication and culture, not either-or, but both-and. They work together and are necessary as students try to gain proficiency in their new second language. We move away from “dependence on meta-linguistic demonstration” and towards “performance” aka verbal, written, listening, and reading abilities.

I think Bill sums up the success we as teachers/professors want for our students well: “I try not to think of success in terms of the A-F grading scale. For me, success is constituted by tangible, gratifying progress towards a learning outcome.” Carol also comments that success is if students have improved their communication skills by the end of the semester, not simply achieving a high grade or doing all the homework (things that could reflect a higher competence, but not necessarily.)

These interviews and articles have been important as I establish myself as a teacher during my grad career, and I so look forward to how I can impact my students and help them learn a new language and new cultures.

 ~Ash

*Three articles: ACTFL Proficiency Guidelines, 2012; Foreign Languages and Higher Education: New Structures for a Changing World, 2007; Report of SLA Working Group, 2015
**https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_where_Spanish_is_an_official_language > my blog, I can use wiki if I want